In this article we will explore how to properly analyze a strategic default in connection with any potential tax liability. This is the first article in our new series: Strategic Default Best Practices.
Many homeowners who have strategically defaulted now recognize it can several years for a lender to collect a debt or to foreclose on a property. In fact, many homeowners continue to live in and/or rent their property while strategically defaulting.
It stands to reason that a homeowner who strategically defaults intends to be in a better financial position. The homeowner has not made mortgage payments for several years while living in and/or while renting part or all their property. What a paradox? By not making mortgage payments a homeowner can potentially improve their financial profile. In fact a properly implemented strategic default can create a better financial future for you, your family, or your business. Keep in mind that maintaining a good credit score is not possible when implementing a strategic default. Thus a “credit score" is not an important financial consideration during a strategic default. The primary goals of a strategic default are to protect and increase cash flow, to protect and increase savings, and to protect and preserve wealth/assets; all with the aim of reducing or eliminating the total debt and/or any tax.
There is no free ride when it comes to not paying a debt. In our book, Strategic Default: How To Create A Better Financial Future for You, Your Family, or Your Business we outlined the principle "Debt Is Similar to the Physics Principle of Matter and Energy". There is a principle in physics that matter and energy can neither be created nor destroyed; they can only be rearranged. Debt follows the same lines. Once debt is created it cannot be destroyed unless it is restructured and resolved. Therefore, if a debt is not settled or resolved, then the debt will remain as long as the creditors are legally allowed to chase you for it. For example, a money judgment can last for 20 years in New York. Original lenders and 3rd party debt collectors will always attempt to collect unpaid debts plus interest and penalties. The tax authorities (IRS and states) will always attempt to collect taxes on forgiven debt and/or rental income. Keep in mind that the Mortgage Forgiveness Debt Relief Act ("MFDRA") provides a tax exemption for forgiven debt in certain circumstances. However, the MFDRA is set to expire December 31, 2012 unless the federal government renews the law.
Strategies to Manage Mortgage, Student, Credit Card and Business Loans
Showing posts with label strategically default. Show all posts
Showing posts with label strategically default. Show all posts
Monday, October 15, 2012
Strategic Default Best Practices: Consider The Tax Implications
Friday, March 9, 2012
Think about the Endgame
There is a recent article in the Washington Post entitled A million-dollar mortgage goes unpaid for years while couple fights foreclosure. It is the story of a Maryland couple whom had not made a mortgage payment in over 5 years.
- “The eviction from their million-dollar home could come at any moment. Keith and Janet Ritter have been bracing for it — and battling against it — almost from the moment they moved into the five-bedroom, 4,900-square-foot manse along the Potomac River in Fort Washington. In five years, they have never made a mortgage payment, a fact that amazes even the most seasoned veterans of the foreclosure crisis. The Ritters have kept the sheriff at bay by repeatedly filing for bankruptcy and by exploiting changes in Maryland’s laws designed to help delinquent homeowners avoid foreclosure.”
From the news article we learn that the Ritters purchased their house for $1.29 million. The purchase involved a mortgage loan of $1 million. The monthly mortgage loan payment, at the time, was $7600 a month. So if the the Ritters did not make a $7600 monthly payment for 5 years, they essentially "earned" or saved or spent $456,000 ($7600 per month x 12 months x 5 years). The Ritter’s story raises several important issues for all people who are actively strategically defaulting. First. What do you do with the money saved from not paying a mortgage? Second. How do you keep the proper mindset/focus during a strategic default? Third. What your ultimate objective of a strategic default? Let’s look at the Ritter’s situation to see if we can “glean” their mindset and determine what they did with the $456,000 in additional savings and/or income.
- “During the boom, they set out to become mini real estate moguls, buying properties and flipping them for a profit. In the process, Keith Ritter, 54, [became] a successful real estate investor and landlord with a six-figure income. Then, when the housing market tanked five years ago, the couple found themselves facing multiple foreclosures. The Ritters have tried to negotiate different payment arrangements with their lender to save their posh home near National Harbor, they said, but to no avail. 'It was never our intention to get here and never make a mortgage payment,' Keith Ritter said. 'We don’t believe in living for free.' But he and Janet, a 51-year-old real estate agent, make no apology for using every tactic available to them to stay in their house, including challenging the foreclosure sale in court, requesting mediation and claiming they had a tenant living with them…“When a bank does all it can to save itself, that’s good business,” Keith said. “When a homeowner does the same thing, he’s called a deadbeat.”
Wednesday, October 12, 2011
Debt Defense Must Read Alert: Principles and Strategies for Dealing with Deficiency
The Wall Street Journal reported in its aptly named article House Is Gone but the Debt Lives On that lenders and/or third party debt collectors are suing borrowers for deficiency judgments.
This is not a new issue. This has been a growing concern among borrowers. There is a dawning realization that if a property cannot pay off the mortgage loan balance in full then the borrower will be responsible for the shortage. We talked about deficiency debt in our March 2010 post entitled Plan To Be Followed When You Walk Away From Debt. As predicted, there has been an increase in lawsuits for deficiency judgments.
This current post focuses on principles and strategies that can be a guide towards resolving deficiency debt.
A deficiency debt arises when a property sold at a foreclosure auction cannot generate enough proceeds to pay off the entire loan amount. If a lender can prove to a court that a borrower is personally responsible for the payment of a deficiency debt then the lender can obtain a deficiency judgment against a borrower. A deficiency judgment is a court order that directs a debtor to pay the lender a certain amount of money. A deficiency judgment includes the principle balance, unpaid interest, legal fees, escrows, and/other costs. A deficiency judgment allows the lender to collect interest until the balance is paid in full. It provides a lender with various tools to collect the judgment such as the right to garnish wages, the right to place a hold on a bank account, and the right to place a lien on personal property or real estate. A deficiency judgment can appear on a credit report. If you are not clear about deficiency debt please read the article What Everyone Should Now About Debt Forgiveness, Obligations, and Deficiency.
- The property is sold to the highest bidder or,
- The lender takes the property in full satisfaction of the debt or,
- The borrower redeems the property by paying in full at auction.
If a lender takes the property at an auction then there is no deficiency debt arising from the loan made by the lender. If the lender decides to take a cash bid at an auction, instead of the property, then the borrower may be responsible for the difference between the total amount due on the loan and the amount collected from the cash bid.
Keep in mind that an auction may not always eliminate a second mortgage and/or Home Equity Line of Credit ("HELOC"). A foreclosure auction typically deals with the loan that is the subject of the foreclosure lawsuit. A foreclosure lawsuit is usually started by the first lien mortgage lender. A borrower can still remain liable for a second mortgage and/or HELOC after the first lien mortgage lender takes the property at an auction.
Each state has specific laws governing the collection of a deficiency debt. In some cases, states prohibit the creditor from seeking more than the collateral used to secure the loan. This is called “non-recourse” or “anti-deficiency.” This means that a creditor cannot hold the borrower personally liable for more than the value of the property at the time of sale. In a “recourse” jurisdiction such as Ohio, if a borrower owes a lender an $100,000 deficiency after a foreclosure sale, then the lender can sue the borrower for the difference, i.e., get a deficiency judgment against a borrower. You can learn more by reading What Is The Difference Between Non-Recourse and Recourse States.
The WSJ article contained important points which should serve to remind all strategic defaulters about the need to develop a written action plan. The following are the main points from the article:
Thursday, October 21, 2010
Got Questions? Get Answers... RH Wants To Protect His Daughter's College Fund After Strategic Default
Got Questions?
I would like to do a strategic default, however, I'm concerned that BOA will be allowed to take my daughter's college fund, which is only $17,000, and also pursue me relentlessly for years. Is this true for residents of North Carolina? Our home, which we paid $385,000 for three years ago is now worth $290,000, which is less than we owe. We can just about afford to stay and pay all of our bills but this could change if our income goes down even slightly. Thanks for any advice you can give. RH
Get Answers...
Monday, July 12, 2010
Got Questions? Get Answers...KL Wants To Strategically Default In Colorado - Can The Bank Come After Him?
GOT QUESTIONS?
Hi,
I am considering strategic default and am wondering how Colorado state law will effect strategic default within CO. Can the bank come after the debtor for the balance?
Thanks,
KL
GET ANSWERS…
KL
Thanks for writing.
You are essentially asking is Colorado is a recourse or non-recourse state. It is my understanding that Colorado is a recourse state therefore a lender may have the right to collect on the unpaid mortgage balance after your property is sold.
Read the following link to learn about debt deficiency, forgiveness, and obligations and the link on recourse and non-recourse states.
I advise you to speak with a legal professional that is familiar with Colorado’s foreclosure laws, debt laws, deficiency laws, recourse laws, and collection laws.
Thank you.
Augustine A. Diji
Hi,
I am considering strategic default and am wondering how Colorado state law will effect strategic default within CO. Can the bank come after the debtor for the balance?
Thanks,
KL
GET ANSWERS…
KL
Thanks for writing.
You are essentially asking is Colorado is a recourse or non-recourse state. It is my understanding that Colorado is a recourse state therefore a lender may have the right to collect on the unpaid mortgage balance after your property is sold.
Read the following link to learn about debt deficiency, forgiveness, and obligations and the link on recourse and non-recourse states.
I advise you to speak with a legal professional that is familiar with Colorado’s foreclosure laws, debt laws, deficiency laws, recourse laws, and collection laws.
Thank you.
Augustine A. Diji
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)