Showing posts with label debt deficiency. Show all posts
Showing posts with label debt deficiency. Show all posts

Wednesday, May 27, 2015

Got Questions? Get Answers... MD Is Concerned About Her Family's Future And Is Considering Strategic Default

Got Questions?

To Whom it May Concern;


I came across the term 'strategic default' recently while researching the idea of letting my home go into foreclosure. I am not a homeowner struggling to pay my bills, I have excellent credit and not very much credit card debt.  I was looking for a way to avoid bankruptcy if possible.


I purchased my home about 7 years ago.  I was a single mom of 2 young boys and my tiny, 2 bedroom ranch made perfect sense for us at the time.  I planned on making improvements over the years and being able to some day sell my home and make a profit.  However, we are now desperate for a bigger home and unfortunately owe more than I could sell it for.  I have talked to representatives with HARP who say that because I have no trouble paying my mortgage that they can't help me. I have talked to my mortgage servicer and they can't help me either.  I would not qualify for a short sale, deed in leiu or even to refinance.


I struggle with this idea feeling that staying here and paying my mortgage every month is the morally right thing to do but this home no longer suits our needs as a family and is in need of repairs that I simply cannot afford. I met with a "real estate" attorney thinking he could help guide me.  He had never heard of strategic default or the mortgage debt relief act.  He was unable to tell me anything.  He said I was asking a lot of what if type questions he couldn't answer.  He told me because I pay my bills I should simply keep doing that.


I came across your website and it said you offer consultation on such a process and to email you.  So, I would appreciate any information you could provide to help guide me in the path that is right for my family and I.


Thanks for your time.


Sincerely,

MD

Get Answers...




Wednesday, July 31, 2013

Latest News 7-31-2013

New law tightens foreclosure rules in Minnesota 7-31-2013
Minnesotans who have struggled to make their mortgage payments will get new leverage for saving their homes beginning Aug. 1 under a law that tightens foreclosure rules in the state. The new law doesn’t necessarily spare homeowners from losing their properties… it seeks to ensure that eligible borrowers have fair and clear access to every available option to avert foreclosure. The law also bans so-called “dual tracking” of foreclosures… [Where] a lender and/or mortgage servicer can’t move to sell a home until the borrower has had a fair chance to seek a loan modification. Read More at MINNPOST

Boca Raton homeowner wins multi-million dollar foreclosure suit after legal misstep 7-26-2013
A Boca Raton homeowner whose waterfront mansion has been in foreclosure since 2008 had her case voluntarily dismissed by her lender Thursday in Palm Beach County court after a legal misstep during trial. Homeowner Valerie Kaan bought the 13,000-square-foot home in 2003 for $8.4 million. The outstanding balance as of Thursday was up to about $10 million… “Maybe this will send a message to banks that when people come to the table in good faith with a reasonable offer, they should more seriously consider it,” said homeowner attorney Roy Oppenheim. Read More at The Palm Beach Post

Lenders seek court actions against homeowners years after foreclosure 6-15-2013
Lenders are filing new motions in old foreclosure lawsuits and hiring debt collectors to pursue leftover debt, plus court fees, attorneys’ fees and tens of thousands in interest that had been accruing for years. It’s all part of a legal process known as a “deficiency judgment,” which is allowed in the District and 40 of 50 states, including Maryland and Virginia. Freddie Mac spokesman Brad German said Freddie Mac is targeting “strategic defaulters,” which the agency defines as “someone who had the means but chose to go into default, that there were no extenuating circumstances that affected their ability to pay…” Read More at The Washington Post

Monday, March 12, 2012

Got Questions? Get Answers...MRA Wants A Strategic Default Plan

Got Questions?

Hi. My husband and I are thinking about walking away from our home. We live in Illinois and purchased our home in 2005 for $157,000. In December of 2006 we got a 2nd mortgage HELOC of $18,000. Maxed that on credit card debt and medical bills. In January of 2010 I lost 10% of my pay because of the recession and my husband would work over time all year up until then too. So we lost all that money as well. We were very dependent of his OT. We fell behind on our 1st mortgage. The most was 3 months behind. Finally in November 2010 we got approved and accepted a loan modification on our 1st mortgage with BOA and our principal balance was lowered to $145,000 and the payments we were behind were forgiven. I never notified my 2nd bank HELOC or ever fell behind on payments with the 2nd loan. I am only paying the minimum interest payments. My 2nd loan is with my Credit Union that I have banked with for 20+ years (dont know if that matters). Oh and the loan they gave me as the HELOC, would need to be paid back by end of 10 years. Well that isn’t going to happen. So now I have fallen 1 month behind on my 1st mortgage with BOA. Still paying my 2nd on time. Have looked on zillow.com to see that my home is currently worth on their website $91,700. It needs a ton of work not to mention. Needs a new kitchen as I think its the original kitchen from when the house was built in 1960. The bathroom is full of mold and the basement is 1/2 finished. And also, my husband and I have maxed out our credit cards AGAIN which is about $10,000 total. I need a new car as the one I have has 198k miles and my husband and I just purchased a used one last year that we still owe $5k on. We are thinking of just buying a new car for me and then just walking away. We don’t think it’s worth paying for something that is worth almost 1/2 of what we owe on it and not to mention the additional money it needs to fix it up. I'd like to actually pay off my credit cards when I walk away, but don’t know if just filing for bankruptcy for everything EXCEPT the cars would be best.

Can you help me? I so look forward to your advice.


MRA



Get Answers…

Sunday, March 4, 2012

Debt Defense 101: The Must Know Rules Of Debt Defense

The basic rules of Deficiency Debt Defense 101 are an ever growing list of MUST DO and MUST IMPLEMENT RIGHT NOW basic strategies in order to achieve the goal of deficiency debt defense.

Deficiency debt also known as debt deficiency arises when collateral that is used to secure a loan cannot satisfy the total amount due on the loan. It happens most often with debt involving real estate. However, it can occur in other types of collateralized loans such as car, business, and equipment loans. When a loan goes unpaid, the lender has the right to auction off the property to pay off the debt. If the lender collects less than what is owed at the sale, the shortage is called debt deficiency. A lender can turn a debt deficiency into a deficiency judgment. Please read What Everyone Should Know About Debt Forgiveness, Obligations and Deficiencies to learn more about debt deficiency and the consequences of a deficiency judgment.

The primary goals of deficiency debt defenses are to:

1. Reduce the Risk and Amount of Deficiency Debt.
2. Strengthen Your Defenses Against Deficiency Debt.
3. Lengthen The Time To Pay Back The Deficiency Debt.

A proper defense requires that you plan and prepare now. So make sure to implement all of these rules. Make sure you come back and read these rules every month. We will be adding new rules along the way. Also, each rule will be further detailed and expanded in future blog posts. We will do our best to apply each rule to a real life scenario.

In the meantime start reading and start preparing.

1. Do not ignore any legal papers. Always prepare a defense to every legal action. Always respond to a legal action in writing. It LENGTHENS the time and STRENGTHENS your defense 100% of the time.

2. Try to save every debt collection message with a live voice on your answering machine. Save messages that appear to be aggressive, intimidating, or threatening.  It may be useful if you need to prove a creditors improper tactics. Make sure you keep track of calls about your debts to other people or businesses.  There are creditors who may contact family, friends, or business associates. This must be stopped. You can use a cease and desist letter to try and put a stop to phone call communications. 


Saturday, July 2, 2011

Planning For A Strategic Default Series : Putting Together Your Financial Snapshot and Gathering Documents


In our last post in our Planning For A Strategic Default Series we wrote about the importance of Developing an Action Plan before initiating a strategic default. We are now going to focus on preparing an income and expense form and gathering documents. These are steps 2 and 3 respectively of Chapter 8 from our guide book Strategic Default: How To Create A Brighter Financial Future For You, Your Family Or Your Business. Chapter 8 provides an introductory step-by-step guide on how to successfully initiate and complete a strategic default. 


If you are like most strategic defaulters, in addition to owning underwater property, you possess other types of debt such as school loans, business loans, credit cards, and home equity lines of credit.  

Remember. The primary objectives of a strategic default are cash flow protection, savings preservation, and wealth protection. So putting together a financial worksheet and keeping proper records is an important step towards your objectives. All of these objectives point to one inescapable conclusion. Your ultimate objective is to be in a better financial position by the end of a strategic default.  

So let's take a look at steps 2 and 3.

Tuesday, December 21, 2010

Got Questions? Get Answers...AR Wants To Protect His Retirement

Got Questions?

Enjoyed your book, but it doesn't address retirees walking away from a home. What assets can a bank pursue if I'm retired & walking away from a home I own in NJ? I've been told retirement money (401K, pension, social security, bank accounts) are Teflon from all except the IRS. Is this accurate? Please clarify.

Thanks

AR



Get Answers...

Sunday, July 11, 2010

Got Questions? Get Answers...DF's Question & Answer Is A Must Read!!!

GOT QUESTIONS?

Firstly, I want to thank you for your site which has provided some invaluable insight into the possibility of strategic defaulting.

My husband and I have been challenged by the recent downtown in the housing market. We have a home (on which I’m the primary, my husband the secondary borrower). We also have condos each (each of us are primary borrowers on one of them). The home is now worth $300,000 less than the $1.2million we paid for it (and $100,000 less than our mortgage). The condos are worth approximately half of the $600,000 we paid for them. I have just lost my job, and job prospects look bleak for me at this time. My husband is working, but cannot cover all of the mortgages.

We have been considering strategically defaulting on all of the properties and moving into a rental property and simply cutting all our losses (effectively starting again). We have also considered strategically defaulting on the home and living in one of the condos (we think this I the better solution). My husband could pay the mortgages for both condos, they are not in a location which can be rented. We’re concerned about the ramifications of such an action however, we are sure that at this point, we must lose at least one of the properties we are making mortgage payments on.

We realize we are in a recourse state (GA). How will my being first on the note affect my husband who is second? Any deficiency awarded against me solely at this point cannot be satisfied as I have no income. As my husband is the only one who is working, how likely is it that any such deficiency will be garnished against his wages?

Thank you for any help you can provide.

DF

GET ANSWERS…

DF, thank you for contacting me.

First things first. You and your husband are equally liable and equally responsible for the mortgage loan if you signed the note and your husband signed the note. I am being specific about the note not the mortgage. A lender or creditor will not differentiate between who signed the note first or last, as long as it has been signed by each party. The note a.k.a. promissory note gives a lender the right to collect all of the money from any person who signed the note. A note is evidence of a loan of money. A mortgage is a security lien against the property. A mortgage is not a promise to pay money.

The primary risk of a strategic default is a deficiency debt. The other risks are:

1. Lower credit score.
2. Loss of the home or property to a foreclosure sale.
3. Recently,
Fannie Mae implemented a rule that bans a person from
obtaining a Fannie Mae mortgage
, if that person strategically defaults. The ban last for seven years. Furthermore, the United States Government may pass a law that bans a person from obtaining a government insured loan, if that person strategically defaults.
4. Debt collections tactics, including mail, letters, personal visits to the
property, phone calls to cell phone, work, and/or family members. Not all debt collection tactics are legal. You should become familiar with your state’s debt collection protection laws and the
Fair Debt Collections Protections Act.

However, my experience has established that most people who strategically default are most concerned about deficiency debt. Most people do not want to be chased down for more money by creditors or lenders.

Let’s go through deficiency debt issues carefully.

A deficiency judgment is an unsecured money judgment against a borrower whose mortgage foreclosure sale did not produce sufficient funds to pay the underlying promissory note or mortgage loan, in full.

You mentioned that you live in a recourse state. You appear to understand that a recourse state allows the lender or creditor to seek an unsecured money judgment for any deficiency. Also, a deficiency judgment has a time period. In some states a deficiency judgment can last up to 20 years. So even if you have no income now, you may have income in the future. Read this link about Recourse and Non-Recourse states to learn more.

If a lender or creditor forgives the deficiency then you will not be exposed to a deficiency judgment. When a lender or creditor agrees (IN WRITING) to forgive a debt as opposed to seeking a deficiency judgment, then the forgiven debt may be considered income by your state taxing authority and the IRS. Forgiven debt is income.

Now consider this. Under current Federal Law if a debt is forgiven on a primary residence then there is no tax due to the IRS. However, this rule may not apply to state tax law.

Read about
debt obligations, deficiency, and forgiveness so you can better understand everything that I have written so far.

So, if you consider strategically defaulting on your (primary residence) home AND you can negotiate debt forgiveness with your lender, then you will not have any exposure to a deficiency judgment and you will not have any federal tax liability.

The question is What Does It Take To Get The Lender To Agree To Forgive Your Debt?

The answer is: you must successfully negotiate a principle reduction, short sale, or a deed-in-lieu of foreclosure AND get the lender to agree (IN WRITING) to forgive any deficiency. You want the creditor or lender to give up its right (IN WRITING) to seek a deficiency judgment.

A principle reduction is when a lender or creditor agrees to reduce the principle balance of a loan.

A deed-in-lieu is when you enter into a written agreement to give the property back to the bank. The key is to negotiate a full settlement of your total outstanding mortgage debt including fees and penalties in exchange for the deed to your property. A full settlement of your total outstanding mortgage debt eliminates a deficiency and tax liabilities. A partial settlement still leaves open the possibility of a deficiency judgment or forgiveness of the remaining balance.

A short sale occurs when a lender let’s you sell your property for an amount less than what is owed on the mortgage. Essentially your lender may be willing to accept less than the full amount due on a mortgage. If you owe the lender $400,000 then the lender may agree to let you sell the property for $350,000.

In all the above cases you must get the lender to agree to forgive the deficiency.

Beware of the
Turn In Your Financial Documents Trap. This happens when the lender’s representative asks you to turn in your financials via telephone or fax in order to see if you qualify for a loan workout, principle reduction, deed-in-lieu, or short sale. Before you agree to turn over your financial documents ask the lender to send you something in writing stating that they will seriously consider a work out option if you turn over your financials. Or ask the lender to direct you to their website regarding their loan workout processing rules. The problem I have is this: What happens to your financial documents, if your lender refuses to negotiate a loan workout? Can the lender use this information against you? For example, can the lender use the information during a foreclosure action or during a lawsuit seeking a deficiency judgment? In order to collect on a properly obtained deficiency judgment, the creditor or lender must locate your bank account, or locate your investment account or locate your place of employment or locate any other asset that has value. I don’t think anyone wants to turn over their financial documents to be used in any way to take their money.

If you do decide to turn over financial documents to the creditor or lender, then cross out all of the account numbers. If the creditor or lender refuses to work with you after you have turned over your financial documents then immediately move all of your money and your investments to another financial institution.

A creditor or a lender has the right to garnish wages if it properly and legally obtains a deficiency judgment in a court of law against a person who entered into a legal loan agreement with the creditor or lender. So yes, your husband could be exposed to wage garnishment if the creditor or lender successfully obtains a deficiency judgment against him.

Keep in mind that even if a creditor or lender successfully obtains a deficiency judgment, it does not mean all is lost. You can negotiate a settlement with the creditor or lender. The creditor or lender may take 50% or less than what is owed instead of spending time in court. Also keep in mind to NEVER LET A LAWSUIT FOR A DEFICIENCY JUDGMENT GO UNDEFENDED. NEVER IGNORE THIS TYPE OF LAWSUIT. The simple reason is that you may stop the creditor or lender from getting a judgment or you may be able to use your defense to this lawsuit as a means to negotiate a settlement.

You should seriously consider working with a qualified attorney and/or accountant in order to understand your specific risks.

You have to make some difficult choices. I am confident that once you understand you options you will get through this successfully.

Wednesday, June 9, 2010

Got Questions? Get Answers...WW Wants To Know Consequences of Walking Away From Old Home For A New Home

GOT QUESTIONS?

My wife and I have been trying to sell our home for nearly a year. We have had little or no traffic no matter how much I lower the price. We CAN afford the payments, it's just that the home has become way too small for our family size.

I have been pre-approved for another loan on a much larger house with the payments being almost identical. This would be a new build and the loan would be in place before I defaulted on my current mortgage. I was approved to carry both mortgages.

What are the consequences besides taking a credit hit if I default? My wife and I are both over 750 credit rating. Are there any other options for my situation?

GOT ANSWERS…..

If you default, in addition to the negative impact to your credit score, you may be responsible for a deficiency. A deficiency is the difference between what a lender is owed on a mortgage and what it receives. I will explain this in more detail later.

If you want to keep your credit intact, you may consider selling the property at loss and covering any short fall out of pocket. For example, if you find a buyer for your home at $400,000 and your closing costs including the money you owe the bank are $425,000, then you can come up with the $25,000 short fall at closing. Another alternative is you can look for a tenant for current property to cover the monthly carrying costs when you decide to move. You may have to cover the difference from the rental amount and the carrying expenses. Of course, the key questions are: how long are you willing to carry the house and when will you be able to sell the house?.

If you decided to default, you have various options.

You can utilize a short sale, deed-in-lieu, loan modification or let the property go to foreclosure sale. All of these options will negatively impact your credit and will expose you to a possible deficiency.

A short sale occurs when a lender let’s you sell your property for an amount less than what is owed on the mortgage. Essentially your lender may be willing to accept less than the full amount due on a mortgage. If you owe the lender $400,000 then the lender may agree to let you sell the property for $350,000. Keep in mind that the $50,000 difference will become a deficiency. A deficiency balance can be forgiven or it can become a judgment. If the deficiency is forgiven then there may be a tax liability. The lender may refuse to forgive the deficiency and instead seek a deficiency judgment. This is a legal judgment obtain by a lender after filing the proper legal paperwork in court. If the lender successfully obtain a deficiency judgment then the lender has the right to seize the cash in your bank accounts, garnish wages, or place a lien on personal property, business assets or real estate.

A deed-in-lieu is when you enter into a written agreement to give the property back to the bank. The key is to negotiate a full settlement of your total outstanding mortgage debt including fees and penalties in exchange for the deed to your property.

You may be able to modify the loan for a lower payment or a reduction in the principle balance.

If you let the property go to foreclosure sale then the lender will sell your property at an auction. If the lender takes the property back then you will not have any deficiency. If the lender sells the property at auction for less than what is owed then there will be a deficiency.

You may not owe a deficiency in certain circumstances. The Federal Mortgage Forgiveness Debt Relief Act and Debt Cancellation provides relief to homeowners from paying taxes on any forgiven debt. Also certain states have anti-deficiency statues. This means that state law prevents a lender from pursing a borrower for any debt deficiency. A state that prevents a lender from pursing a borrower for any debt deficiency is called a non-recourse state.

Please read the following articles and posts. This will help you significantly.

What You Need To Know About Debt Forgiveness, Obligations, and Deficiency.

Recourse v. Non-Recourse State.

Bottom line. Your primary risk is any deficiency.


Tuesday, April 13, 2010

Strategic Defaulters Be Aware : Lenders Will Go After Borrowers Personally For Unpaid 2nd Mortgages aka Junior Liens

The Wall Street Journal's recent report Second Mortgages Vex Borrowers by James R. Hagerty outlines lenders decision to go after borrowers for unpaid second mortgages.

There are borrowers who have second mortgages on their property. The second mortgage can be the "20" from an "80/20" loan. Essentially an "80/20" loan allowed a primary lender to lend 80% of the purchase price. A secondary lender would lend 20% of the loan price. This added up to 100% of the purchase price thereby allowing a property buyer to put very little money down. The second mortgage aka junior lien can also be a home equity line of credit ("HELOC"). Many borrowers took out a HELOC as a way to have extra cash. A borrower could draw against the HELOC when they needed cash. They turned their property into cash machine. Whether it was a "20" of the "80/20" or a HELOC, these second mortgages held a higher interest rate then the first mortgage. Furthermore, most of these second mortgages are essentially unsecured. Now that property prices values have declined significantly and property owners are "upside down", there is no way a lender can collect on the second mortgage from a foreclosure sale or short sale. There is not enough money.

The WSJ points out that according to Federal Reserve Date there are "$1 trillion of junior-lien mortgages outstanding in the U.S. at the end of 2009".

So how can lenders collect on 1 trillion dollars worth of second (junior-lien) mortgages when lenders cannot collect from the sale of a property? The lender can sue.

Understanding this is very important to borrowers with second mortgages. Basically, the lender will sue a borrower personally for the amount that is owed. Even if a lender cannot collect on a second mortgage through foreclosure or sale of the property, the lender has a right to sue the borrower personally. A second mortgage is a debt obligation that is secured by a piece of property and secured by a borrowers personal promise to pay. Please read What Everyone Should Know About Debt Forgiveness, Obligations and Deficiency to better understand debt obligations.

In the past, lenders would write this off. Lenders did not want to incur the costs of chasing a debtor. Also, lenders did not have 1 trillion dollars worth of second (junior lien) mortgages outstanding. This is a lot of money sitting on the table.

This is also big businesses. Debt collection companies are purchasing these second mortgages at cents on the dollars. For example a debt collection company may purchase a second mortgage originally valued at $150,000 for $50,000. The debt collection company can locate the original borrower and offer the borrower a 50% reduction on the $150,000. At 50% of $150,000, the borrower agrees to pay $75,000, The debt collection company offers the borrower a two, three, or four year payment plan. The debt collection company has made a tidy profit on a $50,000 debt purchase.

A lender holding a second mortgage does not have to wait until a foreclosure or sale of the property. A lender can sue the borrower anytime after a default in the payment.

Keep in mind, when a borrower decided to strategically default, in most instances the borrower has sufficient income and assets to keep paying. It is not difficult for a lender to investigate a borrower's financial profile. In other words, lenders will aggressively go after strategic defaulters since it is likely a lender will collect something instead of nothing.

There are state and federal laws that protect borrowers in certain circumstances. It is necessary to get professional advice regarding all available options.

To quote from the WSJ article, "A spokeswoman for Bank of America said that if efforts to avoid a foreclosure failed, "then we do reserve the right to recover the unpaid balance on the second lien if permissible by state law. However, our practice has been to only to pursue recovery in situations where we believe the customer has sufficient nonretirement assets to satisfy their debt obligation."

Any person considering a strategic default : Be Aware.

Tuesday, February 23, 2010

What is the Difference Between Non-Recourse & Recourse States?

State laws regulate the actions that creditors can take when trying to collect on a secured loan. In some cases, states prohibit the creditor from seeking more than the collateral used to secure the loan. This is called “non-recourse” or “anti-deficiency,” meaning that a creditor cannot hold the borrower personally liable for more than the value of the proprety at the time of sale. Generally, in a non-recourse state, if a lender cannot recoup its loan from the sale or seizure of the asset used for collateral, then the relevant state law will limit the lender’s ability to collect from the borrower.

In a non-recourse state, if you default on your home loan, the bank can only foreclose on the home. If the sale proceeds are not enough to repay the loan, the bank cannot take further action or the bank is limited on what it can collect. For example, in a non-recourse jurisdiction such as California, if a borrower owes a lender a $100,000 deficiency after the completion of a short sale or a foreclosure sale, under most circumstances the lender cannot get the money from the borrower. Each state implements “non-recourse” or “anti-deficiency” laws differently.

As of this writing, the following states have some form of non-recourse or anti-deficiency law:



Alaska, Arizona, California, Connecticut, Iowa, North Carolina, North Dakota, Minnesota, Montana, Oregon, and Washington
.

There are also “one-action” states, which means that lenders are only permitted a single legal action to collect mortgage debt. Individual state laws vary. In New York, for example, a lender must choose between the actions of suing to collect the debt or foreclosing on the property. The following states have some type of one-action statute:

California, Idaho, Montana, Nevada, New York, and Utah.

In a recourse jurisdiction such as Ohio, if a borrower owes a lender a $100,000 deficiency after a short sale or a foreclosure sale, the lender can chase the borrower for the difference, i.e., get a personal judgment against a borrower. However, most recourse states have very strict rules governing the process of obtaining deficiency judgments. If a lender does not follow the rules in a recourse state, then it may not be able to obtain a deficiency judgment. For example, under New York State law, a lender must file for a deficiency judgment within 90 days after the foreclosure sale of the property.

As of this writing, these are the recourse states:

Alabama, Arkansas, Colorado, Delaware, District of Columbia (D.C.), Florida, Georgia, Hawaii, Illinois, Idaho, Indiana,  Kansas, Kentucky, Louisiana, Maine, Maryland, Massachusetts, Michigan, Mississippi, Missouri, Ohio, Nebraska, Nevada, New Hampshire, New Jersey, New Mexico, New York, Oklahoma, Pennsylvania, Puerto Rico, Rhode Island, South Carolina, Tennessee, Texas, Utah, Vermont, Virginia, West Virginia, Wisconsin, and Wyoming.  

State laws vary. If you are considering a strategic default, consult your state law regarding the creditor’s rights to collect.