Showing posts with label fannie mae. Show all posts
Showing posts with label fannie mae. Show all posts

Friday, August 13, 2010

Debt Defense 101 : Whistle Blower Says Fannie Mae Took Homeowner's "Trial Mod" Payments With No Intention Of Permanently Modifying Loans

Now this is an issue for anyone who is considering a strategic default or trying to get a loan modification. Many times, a person decides to strategically default after being refused a loan modification. In certain circumstances the homeowner has made monthly "trial mod" payments while waiting for approval of a permanent loan modification ONLY to be rejected later. This happens quite often under the Federal Government's HAMP (Home Affordable Modification Program) aka Making Home Affordable program. The HAMP program was created for homeowners to avoid foreclosure. Instead, it has lined the "wallets" of Fannie Mae and other lenders with tax payer money.

Now why would homeowners make monthly "trial mod" payments if they knew they would be rejected? They wouldn't. However, homeowners are duped into making the payments.

Consider this: If a homeowner is able to make monthly "trial mod" payments as agreed, why doesn't the lender agree to a permanent loan modification. What better proof does a lender need regarding a homeowners ability to pay then the fact that the homeowner is actually making the payments under a "trial mod".

The purpose of this post is to show you how to use lending institutions "clear and convincing malfeasance, unfair negotiating and delay tactics, and outright bad faith" against them as a defense to collection efforts and foreclosure. On top of that it can be an offensive tool to get a permanent loan modification.

The defense rule is this: If a lender is unwilling to negotiate a loan modification in good faith (which includes being treated with respect during the application process), then you have the right to use any and all available defenses against a lender to keep your property even if you are not paying.

So let's begin...

The Center for Public Integrity reports that a Fannie Mae whistle blower has claimed that Fannie Mae executives mismanaged the HAMP program and wasted public funds.

The key quote from the article is as follows: "One issue inside Fannie was its push to put as many borrowers as possible into short-term trial modifications, at the expense...of getting qualified borrowers into permanent modifications...Herron charges that Fannie Mae continued in headlong pursuit of 'trial mods' even though it knew many had little chance of becoming permanent. As late as September 2009, barely 1 percent of trial modifications had converted to permanent modifications by the end of their three-month trial...Nevertheless, Fannie preferred doing trials, Herron alleges, because it was eligible to receive incentive payments from the Treasury Department for trial modifications it booked before the end of 2009."

Based upon these allegations, we now know the following:
                      
1. Fannie Mae took monthly "trial mod" payments from homeowners even though Fannie Mae had no intention of providing permanent loan modifications.
2. Fannie Mae was paid by the Treasury Department (with your tax money) for taking home owner's monthly "trial mod" payments.
3. Fannie Mae made "double the money". Fannie Mae had both hands in your pockets and cleaned you out. Fannie Mae took "trial mod" payments while it took tax payer funded incentive payments despite rejecting over 70% of home owner's seeking a permanent loan modification.

So let's do a little math. It was estimated that 1,000,000 homeowners were placed on monthly "trial mod" payments under HAMP through March 2010. So if, on average, each homeowner was making a payment of $1500 per month then Fannie Mae and other lenders were collecting $1.5 billion dollars per month. If the Fannie Mae and other lenders received a $500 to $1000 incentive payment from the Treasury Department for each borrower in a monthly "trial mod" program then these entities collected $500 million to $1 billion dollars.

BTW...WHY DOESN'T FANNIE MAE (OR OTHER LENDERS) GIVE BACK THE TRIAL "MOD MONEY" AFTER IT REJECTS A HOMEOWNER FOR A PERMANENT LOAN MODIFICATION?

And let's not forget, Fannie Mae recently implemented rules to "punish", to "chase" and to "spy on" any homeowner who decides to strategically default.

My Opinion: This can be a strong defense to a foreclosure case, debt deficiency case, or loan modification rejection under the following conditions:

If the homeowner:

1. applied for HAMP aka Making Home Affordable.
2. has made or continues to make monthly "trial mod" payments.
3. has been rejected for a loan modification or has experienced a long delay in a decision to modify their loan.

Then the homeowner can raise the following defenses under the following circumstances:

1. If foreclosure papers are served on a homeowner then one of the defenses should state: "The lender refused to approve me for a loan modification under HAMP aka Making Home Affordable even though the lender took 'trial mod' payments and even though the lender was paid my tax dollars to set me up with a 'trial mod' payment. The lender had no intention of giving me a permanent loan modification. This was claimed by a Fannie Mae whistle blower."
2. If a lender or third party debt collector seeks a deficiency judgment, then one of the defenses should state "At some point in time, the lender took my 'trial mod' payments and received my tax dollars in the form of incentive payments to set me up with a 'trial mod'. The lender should give me back my money because the lender acted in bad faith. The lender knew that it would not give me a permanent trial modification. On top of that the lender has been paid back the loan with my tax dollars. This was claimed by a Fannie Mae whistle blower."
3. When you apply for a loan mod and it's through the HAMP aka Making Home Affordable program ask your lender..."Do you receive incentive payments from the US government if I make monthly 'trial mod' payments? How much are you paid? Will you return my 'trial mod' payments if I am not accepted for a permanent loan modification? Will you continue collection efforts, including foreclosure, while I apply for a loan modification? Will you send me a response to my questions in writing? What address can I send my questions to?"

By the way, these defenses may be applied to any other lender or servicer. Fannie Mae is not the only mortgage company getting incentives under the HAMP program.

Save the outrage for later. This is about minimizing the consequences of a strategic default. This is about keeping and protecting your cash, savings, and investments.

Keep me posted.

Thursday, June 24, 2010

Government Seeks to Punish Ordinary Citizens Who Strategically Default Instead Of Taxpayer Bailed Out Banks, Corporations, & Investors

Yesterday Fannie Mae sent out a press release titled “Fannie Mae Increases Penalties for Borrowers Who Walk Away, Seven-Year Lockout Policy for Strategic Default”.

Before we discuss Fannie Mae’s, lobbyist induced policy let’s make a few points about Fannie Mae a company that is 80% owned by U.S. taxpayers and part of the largest taxpayer bailout in US History.

Fannie-Freddie Fix at $160 Billion With $1 Trillion Worst Case.

Fannie Mae And Freddie Mac Bailouts Could Cost $1 Trillion.

Fannie Mae stock will be delisted from the New York Stock Exchange.

Enough said on that. Now on to the most important parts of Fannie Mae's new policy to attempt to punish strategic defaulters. These are the key parts of the policy:

1. If a borrower walks away and a.) had the capacity to pay or b.) does not complete a work out in good faith (workouts are defined as loan mods, short sales, and deed-in-lieu), then the borrower will be ineligible for any new Fannie Mae backed mortgage loan for a period of seven years from the date of foreclosure.

2. Fannie Mae will actively take legal action to recoup outstanding mortgage debt from borrowers who strategically default in jurisdictions that allow for deficiency judgments. Fannie Mae will be instructing servicers and lenders to essentially SPY on delinquent loans facing foreclosure and ask these same servicers and lenders put forth recommendations for cases that warrant deficiency judgments.

This is Fannie Mae's rationale "We're taking these steps to highlight the importance of working with your servicer," said Terence Edwards, executive vice president for credit portfolio management. "Walking away from a mortgage is bad for borrowers and bad for communities and our approach is meant to deter the disturbing trend toward strategic defaulting.”

Well let’s see. Basically Fannie Mae intends to ban strategically defaulting taxpayers from obtaining a mortgage loan from a company that is owned and financed by taxpayers because taxpayers have decided to stop paying their mortgage. On top of that Fannie Mae will get servicers and lenders to SPY on taxpayers to determine if they are strategically defaulting.

The primary ways in which to determine if a taxpayer strategically defaults are the review of tax returns, bank statements, income, savings, and investments. Then balance that against their expenses and liabilities. HMMMM…how can a servicer or bank get that information? The servicer or bank will request the borrowers financial information in order to process a loan modification, short sale, or deed-in-lieu. It get’s the info by PRETENDING to offer a loan modification by taking monthly TRIAL PAYMENTS and then denying the modification anyway…AKA Making Home Affordable Program (HAMP). It get's the info by PRETENDING to offer a deed-in-lieu and then denying it. It get's that info by PRETENDING to allow for a short sale and then denying it.

Can Fannie Mae, a servicer, or lender use financial information collected from a borrower against them in a proceeding for a deficiency judgment?

Of course the missing piece to the puzzle is: Underwater Properties.

What happens if a taxpayer homeowner can establish that their property is underwater thereby establishing it makes economic sense not to pay the mortgage? Which is what Fannie Mae basically did when it was bailed out on its poor investment choice of purchasing and holding worthless mortgage backed securities. It looks like lenders are hoping that the government will shift more of the loss of valueless homes on to taxpayers.

This comes on the heels of the United States House of Representatives introducing a potential law that has a provision barring "government-backed loans for borrowers who had strategically defaulted–walked away from their homes when they could still afford the mortgage payments."

What about basic contract principles? A mortgage loan is a contract between a borrower and the lender. If the borrower stops paying then the lender has specific rights and remedies contained in the contract. Why is Fannie Mae interfering with a borrowers contractual rights?

Can you say "Easily Influenced By Banking Lobbyist?

Can this be legal?

Is this even CONSTITUTIONAL?

Most importantly, WHY DOESN’T THE GOVERNMENT PUNISH LARGE BAILED OUT BANKS AND BUSINESSES THAT HAVE STRATEGICALLY DEFAULTED?

Why is the GOVERNMENT enforcing ECONOMIC Slavery? Why should any taxpayer waste their money on an asset that has no value. Businesses, investors, governments, and countries strategically default all the time.

Oh I see...our government believes banks and business are too big to fail while taxpayers, ordinary citizens are too small to succeed or protest.

Can you tell I am mad. You should be too.

Tuesday, April 6, 2010

Does Fannie Mae Recognize Strategic Defaults?

The article entitled Fannie Mae Sees Strategic Default on the Minds of Underwater Borrowers by Diana Golobay of HousingWire provides some interesting messages.

The writer states: "A contagion effect within communities is leading borrowers to consider default as an acceptable option in the face of financial hardship, Fannie found. Both delinquent and current mortgage borrowers are more than twice as likely to have seriously considered stopping payment if they know someone who has already defaulted."

MY COMMENT: This is stating the obvious. Essentially a borrower decides to stop payments because its a financial strain. However, the decision to strategically default is not always based on "financial hardship", instead it is based on cash preservation and savings protection. At some point in time the federal government will recognize this.

The writer states: "Kathleen Day, a representative at the Center for Responsible Lending [said] from everything we know, no one defaults if they could possibly stay in their homes...we just don’t see people responsibly walking away. It’s people who are at the end of their economic rope.”

MY COMMENT: Once again this shows the lack of understanding behind the various reasons for a strategic default. A strategic default is all about a person "responsibly walking away."

The writer states: “The public also strongly believes in the importance of upholding the financial commitment involved in buying and owning a home, even during these challenging times when home values have fallen,” said Fannie president and CEO Mike Williams"

MY COMMENT: Ummm. Excuse me. Who is "the public"? Is "the public" the actual homeowners who own a property with a value less than the mortgage balance. It is not rational to continue to hold an asset that has a debt greater than it's worth. The "challenging times when home values have fallen" refer to an unaware property owner bleeding themselves of cash and savings while supporting a worthless asset.

The writer concludes with: “These findings underline the very large number of people whose homes are worth less than their outstanding mortgages and even larger numbers who are worried about covering their costs and expenses generally,” Harris Interactive said in the poll results. If the percentages are converted into numbers, approximately 27m adults believe they are ‘under water’ – that their houses are worth less than their mortgage debts.”

MY COMMENT: If 27 million adults believe they are 'under water' what should they do? It seems as if Fannie Mae doesn't have an answer that can help these people. That is why people are taking their financial matters into their own hands.

Strategic defaults will continue to be an important strategy for homeowners and any other debtor. Our governments seems reluctant to accept the current principles of strategic default. While understandable, it still pushes the concept that "society" must uphold its financial commitment to make payments on worthless assets thereby bleeding all cash and savings. Unfortunately, we did not hear the same call about upholding financial commitments when trillion dollar bailouts were handed out to some of the largest corporations.

It is all a matter of perspective. Perhaps the our government will come up with an effective solution. For now, homeowners and debtors alike must take their debt matters into their own hands.